On this page
"ST elevation equals STEMI" is a useful first approximation and a poor final position. ST elevation is an electrocardiographic finding with a long differential, and coronary occlusion is a clinical event that does not always produce the textbook finding. Those two facts generate errors in opposite directions, and the same practice fixes both.
Start with the five exercises below: decide, then open the explained answer. After them comes the reasoning that connects them — a set of questions to ask of any trace with ST elevation, and the categories of ECG worth deliberately seeking out until they stop surprising you.
If you want to test this against more traces, work through mimic cases in the app.
Five STEMI-or-mimic traces to interpret
Each exercise gives you the patient, a drawn 12-lead ECG and a written description of it, with the measurements you would take from the paper. Decide whether the ST elevation (or its absence) means occlusion before you open the answer. Four are classic mimics; one is an occlusion that does not meet ST-elevation criteria at all.
Written by Dr. Ezekiel Aluda Osolika, emergency physician (MBChB, FEBEM). Clinical review of this set by the author is pending. All five traces are synthetic teaching traces drawn for this page, not patient recordings; each is simplified to show one teaching point clearly, and the written description gives the measurements. All cases are fictional. Spotted an error? Report a correction and name the exercise.
-
Sharp pain, better sitting forward
Case. A 28-year-old has had sharp central chest pain for a day, worse lying flat and on deep breathing, easier sitting forward. He had a viral illness last week. HR 104, BP 124/78, SpO2 98%.
The ECG. Sinus tachycardia. Concave (saddle-shaped) ST elevation of 1 to 2 mm in I, II, aVF and V2 to V6. PR-segment depression in II and V5 to V6. In aVR, PR elevation and ST depression. No ST depression in any other lead, no Q waves, normal QRS width.
Synthetic teaching trace · full 12-lead ECG (3 × 4 layout, 2.5 s per lead, plus a 10 s lead II strip) · 25 mm/s, 10 mm/mV. Simplified to show the teaching point. Tap to enlarge. Show answer and explanation
Answer: An acute pericarditis pattern: diffuse concave ST elevation with PR depression, and reciprocal change only in aVR.
- Distribution: the elevation spans inferior, anterior and lateral leads at once. It does not respect a single coronary territory.
- Reciprocal change: none, apart from aVR (and sometimes V1), which face the cavity and normally mirror the other leads.
- PR segments: depressed in the limb and lateral leads and elevated in aVR, which reflects atrial inflammation.
- Story: positional, pleuritic pain after a viral illness.
What would change your mind? ST elevation higher in III than II, ST depression in aVL or the lateral leads, convex elevation, new Q waves, or a trace that evolves over minutes. Any of those points towards occlusion, and pericarditis and infarction can coexist.
Next: troponin (a raised value suggests myopericarditis), an echo to look for an effusion, and a repeat ECG. If you cannot confidently separate the two, discuss with cardiology rather than choosing the reassuring label.
Key observation: Diffuse, non-territorial elevation with PR depression and no reciprocal change outside aVR.
-
Crushing pain with a known bundle branch block
Case. A 74-year-old has had crushing central chest pain and sweating for an hour. An ECG from last year shows left bundle branch block. HR 88, BP 104/66, clammy.
The ECG. Sinus rhythm, QRS 150 ms with typical LBBB morphology. In V5, V6 and I the QRS is positive and the ST segment is elevated by 1.5 mm in the same direction as the QRS. In V2 the QRS is a deep S wave of 15 mm with 4 mm of ST elevation. No other change from last year’s trace except the lateral leads.
Synthetic teaching trace · full 12-lead ECG (3 × 4 layout, 2.5 s per lead, plus a 10 s lead II strip) · 25 mm/s, 10 mm/mV. Simplified to show the teaching point. Tap to enlarge. Show answer and explanation
Answer: Concordant ST elevation in V5, V6 and I meets a Sgarbossa criterion: treat as probable acute coronary occlusion.
- What LBBB normally does: the ST segment and T wave point opposite to the main QRS deflection (discordance). Elevation in V1 to V3, where the QRS is negative, is expected.
- What it should not do: ST elevation of 1 mm or more in the same direction as a positive QRS (concordant elevation). That is the most specific of the Sgarbossa criteria, and it is present in three leads here.
- V2: 4 mm of elevation against a 15 mm S wave is a ratio of about 27%. The Smith-modified criteria treat discordant elevation of 25% or more of the preceding S wave as excessive, which points the same way.
Why not wait for troponin? Altered conduction makes ECG diagnosis harder, not irrelevant. Current ESC guidance is that patients with bundle branch block and symptoms suggesting ongoing ischaemia are managed as for STEMI, whether or not the block is old.
Next: activate your reperfusion pathway and get senior and cardiology input immediately. He is also borderline hypotensive, so watch for cardiogenic shock.
Key observation: In LBBB, look for concordance: ST moving the same way as the QRS is not explained by the block.
-
A fit young man after a tackle
Case. A 24-year-old rugby player has left-sided chest wall pain after a tackle. It is sharp, reproduced by pressing on the ribs, and he looks comfortable. HR 56, BP 126/72. A pre-season screening ECG from two years ago is on file.
The ECG. Sinus bradycardia. Concave ST elevation of 1.5 to 2 mm in V2 to V4, with a notch at the J point in V4. T waves are tall but proportionate to large QRS voltages. No reciprocal ST depression, no PR depression, no Q waves, normal R-wave progression. It is identical to the screening ECG.
Synthetic teaching trace · full 12-lead ECG (3 × 4 layout, 2.5 s per lead, plus a 10 s lead II strip) · 25 mm/s, 10 mm/mV. Simplified to show the teaching point. Tap to enlarge. Show answer and explanation
Answer: Benign early repolarisation: stable, concave, proportionate elevation with J-point notching and no reciprocal change.
- Shape and size: concave elevation that is proportionate to tall QRS complexes, with J-point notching, is typical of early repolarisation in young, fit men.
- Absent features: no reciprocal depression, no PR depression, no Q waves, no loss of R-wave height.
- The decisive finding: an identical previous trace. Unchanged findings are a baseline, not an event.
Why not occlusion? Anterior occlusion tends to bring a loss of R-wave height, bulky or broad-based T waves, straightening or convexity of the ST segment, and often reciprocal ST depression in the inferior leads. None is present, and the story is musculoskeletal.
Why not Brugada? The Brugada type 1 pattern is coved ST elevation of 2 mm or more in V1 to V2 with a negative T wave. That is a different shape in different leads.
The caution: early repolarisation is a diagnosis you reach after excluding occlusion, not before. Without the old trace, or with an ischaemic story, repeat the ECG and get the troponin.
Key observation: An identical old ECG is the most powerful piece of evidence on the page.
-
Breathless with long-standing hypertension
Case. A 68-year-old with long-standing, poorly controlled hypertension has two weeks of breathlessness on exertion. No chest pain now. HR 80, BP 172/98. An ECG from six months ago is available.
The ECG. Sinus rhythm. Very large voltages: the S wave in V1 plus the R wave in V5 is 42 mm. ST elevation of 2 to 3 mm in V1 to V3, each following an S wave of 25 to 30 mm. In V5, V6, I and aVL: downsloping ST depression with asymmetric T-wave inversion. QRS 100 ms. Unchanged from six months ago.
Synthetic teaching trace · full 12-lead ECG (3 × 4 layout, 2.5 s per lead, plus a 10 s lead II strip) · 25 mm/s, 10 mm/mV. Simplified to show the teaching point. Tap to enlarge. Show answer and explanation
Answer: Left ventricular hypertrophy with secondary repolarisation change: discordant, proportionate right-precordial elevation and lateral strain.
- Voltage: S in V1 plus R in V5 or V6 above 35 mm meets the Sokolow–Lyon voltage criterion for LVH.
- Right precordial leads: the elevation follows very deep S waves and is small in proportion to them, about 10%. That is the expected discordant change.
- Lateral leads: downsloping ST depression with asymmetric T-wave inversion is the typical “strain” pattern.
- Comparison: unchanged from six months ago.
What would worry you? Elevation that is new, disproportionate to the S wave, convex, or accompanied by ischaemic symptoms; or lateral changes that have changed from the old trace. LVH reduces the ECG’s ability to show ischaemia, so the story and serial troponins carry more weight.
Next: this ECG does not explain or exclude the cause of her breathlessness. Assess for heart failure, and arrange an echo.
Key observation: In LVH, judge right-precordial elevation against the size of the S wave before it.
-
Chest pain with no ST elevation anywhere
Case. A 61-year-old woman has had 30 minutes of central chest pressure, nausea and sweating. HR 92, BP 136/84. This is her first ECG.
The ECG. Sinus rhythm, narrow QRS. No ST elevation in any of the 12 leads. Horizontal ST depression of 2 mm in V1 to V3, maximal in V2, with upright T waves. In V2 the R wave is taller and broader than usual and larger than the S wave.
Synthetic teaching trace · full 12-lead ECG (3 × 4 layout, 2.5 s per lead, plus a 10 s lead II strip) · 25 mm/s, 10 mm/mV. Simplified to show the teaching point. Tap to enlarge. Show answer and explanation
Answer: Record posterior leads and treat as a probable posterior occlusion: ST depression maximal in V1 to V3 with upright T waves is the mirror image of posterior ST elevation.
- Mirror image: V1 to V3 face the posterior wall from the front. Posterior ST elevation appears in them as ST depression, a posterior Q wave as a tall, broad R wave, and inverted posterior T waves as upright T waves.
- Posterior leads: ST elevation of 0.5 mm or more in V7 to V9 confirms the pattern.
- Why it matters: current ESC guidance treats isolated posterior infarction as a STEMI equivalent. Labelled as NSTEMI, this patient may wait hours for reperfusion that should happen now.
Even if V7 to V9 are unremarkable, ongoing ischaemic pain with this pattern still warrants urgent discussion with cardiology about immediate angiography. This is the error described further down the page: occlusion that does not look like the textbook.
Key observation: Maximal ST depression in V1 to V3 with upright T waves: think posterior, record V7 to V9.
Next: Compare with a classic inferior STEMI with reciprocal change
Want more learning resources like this? Join The Ship Doctor Dispatch.
Why the label is the wrong starting point
The clinically important question is not "does this ECG meet criteria" but "is a coronary artery occluded right now, and does this patient need reperfusion". Those questions have different answers more often than is comfortable.
Criteria exist because they are reproducible and they perform reasonably at a population level. They were never intended as the sole determinant of a decision in a single patient, and guideline documents are explicit that the ECG is interpreted alongside the presentation, the trajectory and prior traces.
Practically, that means holding two separate conclusions at the same time. First: what does this trace show, described precisely. Second: what is the probability of occlusion given the trace and everything else I know. Collapsing those two into one label is where most errors begin.
Categories that imitate occlusion
Grouping the mimics by mechanism is more durable than a list, because you can reason about an unfamiliar trace if you know which mechanisms are available.
Baseline repolarisation variants
Some hearts produce ST elevation as their normal state, most often in the earlier precordial leads, and it can be substantial. The features that point this way are stability over time, a concordant and proportionate appearance, absence of reciprocal change, and — decisively — an identical previous trace. This category is the single strongest argument for chasing down an old ECG before committing.
Altered depolarisation
Bundle branch block, ventricular pacing, ventricular rhythms and pre-excitation all change the QRS, and repolarisation follows the QRS. Applying narrow-complex thresholds to these traces produces both false positives and false negatives. Specific approaches exist for assessing ischaemia in the presence of altered conduction; they are worth learning properly rather than approximately, and where you are not confident, the patient's presentation and serial traces carry more weight than your reading.
Pericardial and myocardial inflammation
Inflammatory processes can produce widespread ST elevation that does not respect coronary territories. The distribution is the clue: territorial change with reciprocal depression points one way, diffuse change without a reciprocal pattern points another. Neither is definitive, and the two conditions can also coexist.
Metabolic and electrolyte causes
Marked electrolyte disturbance can distort repolarisation dramatically and produce traces that look alarming and territorial. The tell is usually elsewhere on the ECG — conduction changes, T wave morphology, QRS width — which is why running the full reading order matters rather than jumping to the ST segments.
Structural and pressure causes
Ventricular hypertrophy, aneurysmal change after previous infarction, and raised intracranial pressure all have recognised repolarisation effects. Aneurysmal change is a particular trap because it is genuinely fixed: the trace looks like an infarct because there was one, years ago.
Technical causes
Lead misplacement and artefact. Boring, common, and responsible for a meaningful share of unnecessary escalations. Repeating the ECG with careful placement costs three minutes.
Occlusion that does not look like it
The reverse error receives less teaching time and does more harm. Several situations produce genuine occlusion with a trace that fails criteria.
- Territories the standard leads represent poorly. Some regions of myocardium are seen only indirectly, and their infarction can present as depression or as T wave change in the leads that face the opposite wall rather than as elevation anywhere.
- Very early change. Occlusion is a process. A trace recorded in the first minutes may show only subtle T wave changes, and the diagnostic appearance may develop over the following half hour. The countermeasure is serial ECGs at defined intervals, not a single trace.
- Elevation that is real but subthreshold. Millimetre criteria are thresholds, not physiological boundaries. Change that is proportionally significant for the size of the QRS may not reach an absolute cut-off.
- Occlusion with altered conduction. As above — the same feature that generates false positives also masks true ones.
- Patterns recognised as high risk without meeting elevation criteria. Several described morphologies are associated with critical coronary lesions and do not produce elevation. They are worth learning by name from a current cardiology source and worth acting on when the clinical picture supports them.
The unifying countermeasure for all five is the same: when the story is convincing, a non-diagnostic ECG is a reason to repeat it and to keep looking, not a reason to stand down.
Five questions to ask of any elevated trace
Run these in order, before you commit to a label. They take under a minute and they catch most of both error types.
- Is the QRS normal? If not, the thresholds you are about to apply do not apply. Establish this before looking at the ST segments at all.
- Is the change territorial? Contiguous leads corresponding to a vascular distribution, with reciprocal depression in the opposing leads. Territorial plus reciprocal is a strong pattern; diffuse without reciprocal is a different problem.
- Is there a previous trace? The highest-value question on the list. A finding that is unchanged from two years ago is a baseline; the same finding that is new is an event. Chase this before escalating and before standing down.
- Does the ECG match the patient? Not just the symptoms — the whole picture, including how unwell they look, their trajectory, and what else could explain both the trace and the presentation. A dramatic trace in a comfortable patient with an alternative explanation deserves scrutiny.
- What will the next ECG tell me, and when am I recording it? Naming the interval converts uncertainty into a plan. Evolution over fifteen minutes is one of the most discriminating pieces of information available to you, and it costs nothing.
What to do when you are still unsure
Say so, precisely, to someone who reads more ECGs than you. "Two millimetres of elevation in three contiguous leads, no reciprocal change, no previous trace, patient comfortable, I am not confident" is a useful handover. Escalating uncertainty is not indecision; escalating a confident wrong label is the failure mode.
What changes when reperfusion is hours away
In a hospital with a catheter lab, an uncertain trace can be resolved by a rapid specialist opinion and a short journey. At sea, offshore, or at a remote site, the same uncertainty attaches to a much heavier decision: a treatment with real risk, or an evacuation that takes hours and commits significant resources.
Three things follow. Serial ECGs become more valuable, not less, because time is the diagnostic tool you still have. Remote specialist advice should be sought earlier and with a described trace rather than a label, so the person advising can form their own view. And the documentation of your reasoning matters more, because the decision will be reviewed by people who were not there and could not see the patient.
The interpretation skill is identical. What changes is the cost of being wrong in either direction, which is an argument for describing findings precisely rather than reaching for a label early.
A practice plan
Mimics are learned by volume and by consequence. A structure that works:
Deliberately seek out the categories above. Work through a teaching library by mechanism rather than at random, so you meet each category enough times to recognise it. Five examples of each beats fifty random traces.
Always commit before revealing. Write the description, the differential, your confidence, and your action. Then check. Comparing your reasoning to the answer is what produces learning; comparing your verdict alone does not.
Practise with the clinical context attached and then without it. Reading a trace blind trains pattern recognition. Reading it with the story trains the actual bedside task. You need both, and most people only ever do the first.
Keep a list of the ones that caught you. Not the topic — the reason. "Applied narrow-complex thresholds to a paced rhythm" is a rule. "Missed a mimic" is not.
Educational disclaimer
Educational use only. This article describes ECG interpretation principles and differential reasoning for education and simulation. Its exercises use written descriptions of fictional ECGs rather than patient traces, and it is not a diagnostic protocol. It is not medical advice, not patient-specific guidance, and not a substitute for clinical judgement, supervision, local protocols, employer policy or current national guidance. Scope of practice, drug availability and escalation pathways differ by role, employer and jurisdiction — verify every figure against your own formulary and protocols before acting on it.
Sources and further reading
- European Society of Cardiology — Clinical Practice Guidelines (acute coronary syndromes)
- Wagner GS, Macfarlane P, Wellens H, et al. AHA/ACCF/HRS recommendations for the standardization and interpretation of the electrocardiogram: acute ischemia/infarction. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2009.
- Smith SW, Dodd KW, Henry TD, et al. Diagnosis of ST-elevation myocardial infarction in the presence of left bundle branch block. Ann Emerg Med. 2012.
- Resuscitation Council UK — Adult advanced life support guidelines
Guidance is reviewed at least every 12 months, and sooner after a material change to any cited recommendation.